USC speech

February 26, 2008

Edison Chen sex photo scandal

Filed under: Uncategorized — minimax @ 12:35 pm


admit : to agree that something is true, especially unwillingly • assume : to accept something to be true without question or proof  • be to blame : to be the reason for something that happens  • blameworthy : having done something wrong  • candid : showing or describing nudity or sexual acts  • celebrity : someone who is famous, especially in the entertainment business  • claim : to say that something is true or is a fact, although you cannot prove it and other people might not believe it  • damages : money which is paid to someone by a person or organization who has been responsible for causing them some injury or loss  • destroy : to damage something so badly that it does not exist or cannot be used  • doctor : to change a document in order to deceive people  • engaged : having formally agreed to marry  • fault : a mistake, especially something for which you are to blame  • fiancé : the man to whom a woman is engaged to be married  • indefinite : not exact, not clear, or without clear limits  • justified : having a good reason for something  • memento : an object that you keep to remember a person, place or event  • request : when you politely or officially ask for something  • rumor : an unofficial interesting story or piece of news that might be true or invented, which quickly spreads from person to person  • scandal : (an action or event that causes) a public feeling of shock and strong moral disapproval  • sincere : not pretending or lying; honest  • spouse : a person’s husband or wife  • standard : a moral rule which should be obeyed  • statement : something that someone says or writes officially, or an action done to express an opinion  • sue : to take legal action against a person or organization, especially by making a legal claim for money because of some harm that they have caused you  • threaten : to tell someone that you will kill or hurt them, or cause problems for them if they do not do what you want  • upload : to copy or move programs or information to a larger computer system or to the Internet


1 How interested are you in this scandal?

Not at all. 0 · · · · 9 Very interested.

Where did you get most of your information about this scandal? When did you first start paying attention to it? Who have you most often discussed it with? Do you know anyone who is especially interested in the scandal? Why do you think this person is so interested? How do you think the scandal will develop from now?

2 How much do you think Edison is to blame for what happened?

Not at all. 0 · · · · 9 Completely his fault.

What, if anything, do you think Edison did wrong? Who do you think is most blameworthy? Do you think any of the women did anything wrong? Do you think it was a good idea for 阿嬌 to admit that she was in the photographs? If it were you, would you admit it?

3 How justified do you think Edison was in lying during the early stages of the scandal (for example, when he first claimed that the photos were not really of him, but had been doctored)?

A lie is a lie, so he was not justified. 0 · · · · 9 He was just trying to protect the women in the photographs, so he was justified.

Do you believe Edison’s explanation of how the photographs were stolen from him? If they were truly stolen from his computer when it was being repaired as he claimed, why do you think the police are having such a hard time finding the person who uploaded the photographs to the Internet? How do you decide when it’s acceptable for someone to lie? Do you use the same standards for yourself that you use for other people?

4 How willing would you be to have candid photos taken by a lover if they asked?

Absolutely not. All my clothes have to be on and we can’t be doing anything more than holding hands! 0 · · · · 9 Sure. Anything goes!

Do you think the women in Edison’s photographs were probably happy to be photographed? What do you think of Edison without his clothes on? Which of the women in the photographs do you think looks most attractive? If you were photographed that way, would you be worried? What would you be most worried about? Has anyone ever made a request like this of you? Have you ever refused a lover’s request?

5 How likely would you be to take photos of yourself having sex with a lover if he or she were willing?

No way! 0 · · · · 9 All right, yeah! Let’s do it!

Why do you think Edison wanted to take the photos? Do you believe that he deleted them from his computer’s hard disk drive, as he earlier claimed?  Why would you, or why would you not, want to take such photos? If you had such photos, what would you probably do with them? Do you, or would you, tend to keep mementoes of past lovers, such as letters, photos, etc? If a current lover asked you to throw away such mementoes, what would you probably do?

6 If you had candid photographs of yourself with a very attractive celebrity of the opposite sex, would you show them to other people?

No, and I would probably destroy them immediately to make sure nobody ever saw them. 0 · · · · 9 Sure, I’d show them to anyone who asked, and then I would post them on the Internet!

Do you think Edison really didn’t show the photographs to anyone, as he claimed? If he didn’t, how did someone could have discovered them? If you could (or had to) have sex with a celebrity, whom would you choose? Why? If you were a celebrity, would you take advantage of your fame and try to have as many sexual partners as possible?

7 If you discovered there were photographs on the Internet of your fiancé or fiancée having sex with someone else, how much would it bother you (assuming the photos were taken before you met)?

Not at all. The past is the past. 0 · · · · 9 I would cancel our engagement on the spot!

Do you think it’s understandable that 陳思慧’s fiancé plans to cancel their engagement? How would you probably react if you were in her fiance’s position? Do you generally want to know about a lover’s past? How actively do you pursue information about a lover’s past?

8 Do you think 張柏芝’s husband should divorce her (assuming the photos of her were taken when she was married, and not before)?

Definitely not. 0 · · · · 9 Absolutely!

What do you think will probably happen with her marriage? Do you believe the rumors that she threatened to kill herself and their child if her husband looked at the photographs on the Internet? Could you forgive a spouse who had cheated on you? If you could, under what circumstances?

9 What did you think of Edison’s statement last week?

Total bullshit! 0 · · · · 9 I’m satisfied that he said everything that he should have and was sincere about it.

What else, if anything, do you think he should have said? What do you think of Edison statement that he will “step away from the Hong Kong entertainment industry…indefinitely”? Legal experts say that the women could probably win damages from Edison if they sued him—if you were one of the women, would you sue him? 

WARM-UP QUESTIONS : Have you been following the gossip about Edison Chen’s sex photos? Did you see his press conference last week? Have you heard anything new about the photographs since then?




Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: